🥯 Best Bagel Shops in Staten Island, New York
19 bagel shops in Staten Island, New York, ranked by Google rating and number of reviews. Featured listings appear first.
At Poppy Seed Bagels, we're dedicated to preserving the timeless tradition of authentic, hand-rolled, and kettle-boiled bagels. Our mission is to bring the taste of New York-style bagels to our local community and beyond…
Hey, welcome to Brooklyn Bagels and Cafe at 3579 Victory Blvd, Staten Island! We're not your average spot---we're the combo of great bagels, killer coffee, epic sandwiches, and a chill lunch hangout. Our bagels? Hands do…
Local NYC bagel store staple for over 25 years
Bagels R Us is one of the bagel shops listed in Staten Island, New York.
Providing the best quality bagels, sandwiches, and catered needs to all our customers is our main priority!
HOT BAGELS ALL DAY LONG! CATERING AVAILABLE! 10+ VARIETY OF CREAM CHEESE! FRESH BAKED MUFFINS,CROISSANTS, CHEESE DANISH,APPLE TURNOVERS,DONUTS LUNCH SPECIALS! AND MUCH MORE
Nonna's Bagels & Deli is a neighborhood bagel shop and deli in Great Kills, Staten Island, serving fresh bagels, breakfast sandwiches, deli sandwiches, and hot coffee. Known for its quality ingredients and friendly local…
Top Bagels is one of the bagel shops listed in Staten Island, New York.
Bagel Land is one of the bagel shops listed in Staten Island, New York.
Located at 732 Forest Ave, Staten Island, NY 10310, Bagels Bread & Butter operates as a bagel shop serving Staten Island in New York.
Forest Superette Bagels is a bagel shop in Staten Island, New York.
Hillside Farm to Bagel offers fresh hand rolled bagels daily as well as Gluten Free bagels. We offer locally sourced produce as our ingredients & Farm fresh eggs. We also have a full menu of specialty sandwiches & salads…
Located at 486 Forest Ave #5, Staten Island, NY 10310, Bagel Bin operates as a bagel shop serving Staten Island in New York.
Breakfast , Lunch, Deli, Hot Foods , Catering Etc.
Manor Superette & Bagels is one of the bagel shops listed in Staten Island, New York.
Located at 1728 Hylan Blvd, Staten Island, NY 10305, Bagels on the Boulevard operates as a bagel shop serving Staten Island in New York.
Oakwood Bagels is one of the bagel shops listed in Staten Island, New York.
Seaside bagels is a bagel shop in Staten Island, New York.
Located at 99 Guyon Ave, Staten Island, NY 10306, Guyon Bagels operates as a bagel shop serving Staten Island in New York.
Bagel Shops in nearby areas
Other categories in Staten Island
Frequently asked questions
How many bagel shops are there in Staten Island, New York?
The directory currently lists 19 bagel shops in Staten Island, New York, updated continuously from Google Maps.
Which bagel shop in Staten Island, New York is rated highest?
Weighing rating against review count, Poppy Seed Bagels & Catering currently leads with 4.9 out of 5 from 525 reviews.
How is this list ranked?
Featured listings (paid, always labeled) come first; the rest are ordered by a score that balances the average Google rating against the number of reviews, so a 4.8 from 300 reviews outranks a 5.0 from 2.
Can I call these bagel shops directly?
Yes. 18 of the 19 listings on this page show a phone number; tap the call button on each card.
What else does Staten Island, New York have besides bagel shops?
Other well-covered categories in Staten Island, New York include Coffee Shops, Bakeries, Bagel Shops, Ice Cream & Gelato; see “Other categories” below.
My business is missing, how do I add it?
Use the “Add a business” page (free, reviewed within days). If it is already listed, open its page and choose “Claim this listing”.
Missing a cafe or coffee shop? Add it free. Run one of these? Get featured at the top.